| 1974 | A Musical Jewelry Box | Jim Driadon | 16th | 3rd |
| 1970 | A Salute to Jimmy Durante | Harry Straub | 5th | 9th |
| 1989 | A Serenade in Blues | Chris Caniglia | 19th | 13th |
| 1957 | A Show Boat Revue | Harry Straub | 4th | 14th (Tie) |
| 1978 | A Tribute to the King of Rock ‘n Roll | Luke McDermott | 6th | 10th |
| 1956 | American Indians | Harry Straub | 12th | 13th |
| 1959 | American Jubilee | Harry Straub | 15th | 8th |
| 1983 | An Old Fashion Sing-a-Long | Jim Driadon | 7th | 20th |
| 1973 | Ballroom Reflections | Jim Driadon | 4th | 2nd |
| 1966 | Birds of a Feather | Harry Straub | 2nd | 13th |
| 2015 | Brazilliant | Bill Razzano | 2nd | 15th | 16th |
| 1992 | Car-Tunes | Harry Hill | 4th | 15th |
| 1969 | Caribbean Holiday | Harry Straub | 10th | 9th |
| 1964 | Cinderella | Harry Straub | 5th | 13th |
| 1996 | Civil-Un-Rest | Harry Hill | 6th | 17th |
| 2001 | Clowning Around City Hall | Harry Hill | 1st | 15th |
| 1990 | Dial 9-1-1 | Jim Driadon | 1st | 16th |
| 2012 | Fire Fightin’ Follies | John Hicks | 12th | 15th | 17th |
| 1998 | Friday Night at the Frat | Frank Voight Jr. | 2nd | 8th (Tie) |
| 1955 | From the Vine came the Grapes | Harry Straub | 16th | 13th |
| 2013 | Greater O’s Headin’ For The Hills | Bill Razzano | 1st | 16th | 14th |
| 1997 | Greater O’s on the go to Mexico | Frank Voight Jr. | 2nd | 18th |
| 2006 | Greater O’s Stirrin’ the Pot | Perry DiMatteo | 6th | 15th | 15th |
| 2000 | Greater Overbrook’s Still Makin Music | Jim Driadon | 14th | 16th |
| 1972 | Hadfields and McCoys | Jim Driadon | 2nd | 15th |
| 2016 | Havin’ a Hula-Va Mum Time | Bill Razzano | 2nd | 14th | 12th |
| 2008 | Haymazing Adventure | Perry DiMatteo | 3rd | 13th | 13th |
| 1960 | Holiday in Paris | Harry Straub | 15th | 5th |
| 1991 | Hooked on the High C’s | Harry Hill | 11th | 14th (Tie) |
| 2005 | Jest-A-Nother Knight | Joe Anderson | 1st | 16th | 15th |
| 1965 | Jimmy “Schnozzle” Durante | Harry Straub | 13th | 16th |
| 1981 | Jungle Fantasy | Jim Driadon | 12th | 17th |
| 1967 | Mardi Gras | Harry Straub | N/A | 8th |
| 2010 | Memories of the Way We Were | Jim Driadon | 1st | 15th | 17th |
| 2017 | Mum Potion #9 | Bill Razzano | 15th | 15th | 10th |
| 2018 | Mum-In Spoonful | Bill Razzano | 1st | 15th | 11th |
| 1977 | New York, New York | Luke McDermott | 9th | 20th |
| 1994 | On the Road Again | Harry Hill | 4th | 14th |
| 1999 | On the Town in Madhattan | Tom Piccone Jr. | 14th | 16th |
| 1980 | Oscar’s Best Songs | Jim Driadon | 22nd | 13th |
| 2003 | Overbrook’s a Wiz at Oz | Harry Hill | 3rd | 17th | 14th |
| 1993 | Pajammin’ | Harry Hill | 1st | 16th |
| 2009 | Polar-ized | Perry DiMatteo | 4th | 13th | 17th |
| 1984 | Puttin’ on the Ritz | Jim Driadon | 24th | 14th |
| 1986 | Rag Time Revelry | Jim Driadon | 8th | 11th |
| 2002 | Red Hot, Red Garter Revue | Carmen Vitanza Sr. | 17th | 14th | 14th |
| 1975 | Rhapsody in Blue | Jim Driadon | 20th | 15th |
| 2004 | Rock, Pop, and Patriotic | Harry Hill | 2nd | 18th | 17th |
| 1962 | Roman Holiday | Harry Straub | 6th | 12th |
| 1985 | Royal Masquerade | Jim Driadon | N/A | 8th | 4th |
| 1971 | Satan Takes a Holiday | Jim Driadon | 12th | 12th |
| 1979 | Season’s Greetings | Luke McDermott | 10th | 13th |
| 2014 | Show Boatin on Broad Street | Bill Razzano | 9th | 15th (Tie) | 12th |
| 1976 | Showtime ’76 | Jim Driadon | 3rd | 12th |
| 2019 | Spirits of the Canyon | Bill Razzano | 5th | 15th | 15th |
| 1963 | Square Dance Jamboree | Harry Straub | 17th | 11th |
| 1987 | Street Scenes | Jim Driadon | 20th | 12th |
| 1995 | Struttin’ with Billy | Harry Hill | 21st | 17th |
| 1961 | Swamp Fire | Harry Straub | 8th | 4th |
| 1954 | The Knights of the Rose | Harry Straub | 11th | 19th (Tie) |
| 1982 | The Music Man | Jim Driadon | 17th | 13th (Tie) |
| 2011 | The Sidewalks of New York | Carmen Vitanza Sr. | 16th | 14th | 17th |
| 1958 | The Tango | Harry Straub | 17th | 10th |
| 1953 | The Top Hatters | Harry Straub | 12th | 16th |
| 2020 | Under The Lovely London Sky, A Practically Perfect Poppins Tale | Jim Driadon | 13th | 14th | 15th |
| 2007 | Welcome to the Jungle | Perry DiMatteo | 5th | 13th | 13th |
| 1968 | Winter Wonderland | Harry Straub | 7th | 4th |
| 1988 | Woodchoppers Ball | Chris Caniglia | 8th | 16th |